Practice Lifecycle Spotlight

Beyond the National Average

Understanding the Value of the Dental Practice in Front of You
Purchasing the right practiceRecruitment and practice optimizationAppraisals and continuance planningPractice sales

“Averages can provide perspective. They can't tell you what a particular practice is worth.”

Research Is a Good Place to Start

Today’s buyers have access to more information than ever before.

A dentist considering practice ownership can search online for dental practice valuation and quickly find articles, transaction reports, industry surveys and discussions about what dental practices typically sell for. Within a relatively short period of time, a buyer may encounter a national average suggesting that dental practices sell for a certain percentage of annual collections.

Doing that research isn’t a bad thing.

In fact, becoming more informed before making a significant investment is entirely reasonable. The difficulty arises when a national average becomes the basis for determining what a particular practice in a particular market should be worth.

That’s when useful information can become misleading.

The important thing to remember is contained in the description itself:

A national average is an average.

What Does an Average Actually Tell Us?

An average takes many different observations and combines them into a single number.

Those observations may include practices in major metropolitan areas and small rural communities. They may include highly profitable practices and practices with considerably higher overhead. Some may operate from modern facilities with updated equipment while others may require significant investment.

They may also include different practice types, different patient demographics and markets with very different levels of buyer demand.

All of those transactions can contribute to an average.

The resulting number can be interesting and potentially useful as a point of reference. What it cannot do is describe all of the characteristics of the individual practice you’re considering.

That’s an important distinction.

A Practice Exists in a Market

Dental practices aren’t bought and sold in a national marketplace where every opportunity is interchangeable.

They exist in communities.

A practice in a highly desirable market with significant buyer demand may be viewed differently from a similar practice in an area where fewer dentists are looking to purchase. Geography can influence the buyer pool, recruiting environment, real estate considerations and future opportunities available to an owner.

Even within the same state, markets can behave differently.

That’s why applying a national average to a specific practice can overlook one of the most fundamental aspects of value: where the practice actually exists.

Geography isn’t the only consideration, but it provides context that a national percentage simply cannot.

Similar Collections Don’t Necessarily Mean Similar Value

Imagine two practices with approximately the same annual collections.

At first glance, someone using a percentage of revenue might conclude that the practices should have approximately the same value.

But look more closely.

One may have stronger profitability, a well-established hygiene program, updated equipment and a facility capable of supporting future growth. The other may have a different expense structure, different equipment needs or a facility that presents different considerations for a buyer.

One may be located in a market where several qualified buyers are actively looking for practices. The other may be located in an area with considerably less buyer activity.

Their collections may be similar.

Their opportunities are not necessarily the same.

And neither is their value.

Collections Are Important, but They Aren’t the Entire Practice

Collections are understandably one of the first numbers buyers look at. They provide useful information about the size and activity of a practice.

But as we’ve discussed elsewhere in this series, practice value extends beyond collections.

Profitability matters. The patient base matters. The facility, equipment and technology matter. Staffing, hygiene, procedure mix and opportunities for continued growth can all contribute to the overall picture.

The practice’s history and reputation can matter as well.

No single characteristic determines value independently. Together, they help explain why two practices producing similar revenue can represent very different opportunities.

A percentage of collections can provide a reference point.

It cannot capture all of that.

The Danger of Starting With the Answer

One of the challenges with online research is that it can unintentionally create an anchor.

A buyer reads that practices nationally sell for a particular percentage of collections. From that point forward, every practice is evaluated against that number.

If the asking price is lower, the practice may appear inexpensive.

If it’s higher, the buyer may immediately conclude that it’s overpriced.

But neither conclusion can reasonably be reached from the percentage alone.

The better question isn’t:

“How does this price compare with the national average?”

It’s:

“What characteristics of this particular practice support its value?”

That question leads to a much more useful evaluation. It also keeps a buyer from dismissing an opportunity before fully understanding it.

A practice that falls outside an expected national range may have characteristics that make it particularly well suited to that buyer’s goals, clinical interests or future plans. By allowing an average to become a predetermined limit, a buyer may unintentionally overlook an opportunity that could be exceptional for both their immediate circumstances and their long-term future.

That doesn’t mean a buyer should disregard value or pay more simply because a practice is appealing. It means the opportunity deserves to be understood before a national statistic is allowed to define it.

Markets Don’t Read National Averages

Supply and demand influence many types of transactions and dental practices are no exception.

Some geographic areas consistently attract more buyers. Other markets may have fewer potential purchasers despite the presence of healthy, profitable practices.

Those differences can influence how opportunities are perceived and ultimately how transactions occur.

This is one reason national data needs context.

A buyer researching practices online may be looking at information derived from transactions across the country while considering an opportunity in a very specific New England community.

The national data hasn’t become irrelevant.

It simply hasn’t answered the local question.

Dental Practice Appraisal and Valuation Aren’t Quite the Same Thing

When discussing practice value, you’ll often hear the terms appraisal and valuation. They’re related, but they aren’t necessarily interchangeable.

A formal appraisal is generally a more comprehensive process that develops and documents an opinion of value using recognized valuation approaches, supporting financial information and the specific characteristics of the practice. Formal appraisals may be appropriate when a documented opinion of value is needed for purposes beyond a typical sale.

In many practice transitions, however, what is prepared is a valuation. A valuation analyzes the financial performance and relevant characteristics of the practice to develop a well-supported indication or opinion of its value within the context of a potential transaction.

Both involve considerably more analysis than simply applying a national percentage to annual collections. The important point for a buyer isn’t the terminology alone. It’s understanding how the value was developed and what information supports it.

Understanding the Particular Practice

Whether a practice has a formal appraisal or a valuation, understanding value requires looking at the practice itself.

Its financial performance, profitability, assets, patient base, facility and other relevant characteristics can be considered within the context of the practice and its market. The objective isn’t to force the practice toward a predetermined percentage.

It’s to develop a reasonable understanding of value based upon the opportunity itself.

Sometimes that value may appear relatively close to an industry average.

Sometimes it won’t.

Neither result, by itself, tells you whether the value is reasonable.

The supporting information does.

Averages Still Have a Place

None of this means national averages are useless.

They can help buyers develop general familiarity with the marketplace. They can provide context and sometimes prompt worthwhile questions.

What they shouldn’t become is a substitute for understanding the individual opportunity.

This is true well beyond dental practice transactions. Averages are useful because they simplify a large amount of information. Their limitation is that the simplification removes many of the differences that may matter most in a specific situation.

Use the average to become curious. Then learn about the practice.

JKA Insight

We regularly speak with both first-time buyers and experienced owners looking to acquire an additional practice who have done considerable research before contacting us.

We welcome that.

An informed buyer usually asks better questions and approaches an opportunity with greater perspective.

Where we occasionally see confusion is when a national percentage discovered online becomes the starting point and ending point for determining value. A specific dental practice is more nuanced than that.

After decades of appraising, valuing and selling dental practices throughout New England, we’ve seen firsthand how practices with similar collections can represent very different opportunities depending upon their profitability, characteristics and geographic market.

The national average can tell you something about the larger marketplace.

Understanding the practice tells you about the opportunity in front of you.

Questions Worth Asking Yourself

  • Am I using national averages as context or treating them as a valuation?
  • What characteristics of this particular practice may influence its value?
  • How does the practice’s profitability help me better understand the opportunity?
  • What should I understand about the geographic market in which the practice operates?
  • How was the practice’s value developed and what information supports it?
  • If the value differs from what I expected based on online research, have I taken the time to understand why?

Key Takeaways

  • National practice value averages can provide useful context, but they don’t determine the value of an individual practice.
  • Practices with similar collections can have different values and represent very different opportunities.
  • Profitability, practice characteristics and geography can all influence value.
  • Local market conditions may differ considerably from national data.
  • A formal appraisal and a practice valuation are related but aren’t necessarily the same thing.
  • Understanding how a value was developed is more useful than simply comparing it with a national percentage.
  • Relying too heavily on an average can cause a buyer to dismiss an opportunity before understanding what it could mean for their future.

A Final Thought

There’s nothing wrong with beginning your research online.

Just don’t let an average finish the conversation.

A dental practice is an individual business operating in an individual market, with its own financial history, patients, people, strengths and opportunities. A practice that doesn’t fit neatly within a national average may still represent an exceptional opportunity for the right buyer.

Understanding those differences—and taking the time to understand the opportunity before drawing a conclusion—is where understanding value really begins.

Where this fits in the Practice Lifecycle

Purchasing the Right Practice

JKA represents sellers and helps buyers understand what a practice could become under new ownership.

Keep reading

More from this phase

Ready to start a conversation?

Tell us what you have in mind. A conversation costs nothing and commits you to nothing.